Sibling response to living with a brother or sister with a disability

Notes taken from a seminar presentation by Monica Cuskelly during Epilepsy Week, 1996.

Possible positive outcomes:

Altruism, tolerance, orientation towards humanitarian interests, protective sibling relationships, cognitive advancement, increased social skills and roles, social competence, satisfaction through involvement. Information is now coming from fathers and siblings in these families whereas in the past only mothers’ responses were sought.

Possible negative outcomes:

Behavioural problems (older social attitudes showed that there was less tolerance to a family as a whole if one child had a disorder, but recent studies show that differences in behavioural problems seem to be reducing).

Adjustment difficulties:

Some studies found that self esteem is better and that children who have grown up with a disabled sibling have more experience and hence more confidence in tackling day to day problems. Not all studies support this finding.

Common problems in all families:

Competing needs within a family change.

Overidentification:

Brothers and sisters may adopt some of the traits of the child with the disability. Everyone should be informed and understand the full impact of the disability, particularly that it is not contagious or they will not ‘take turns’.

Embarrassment:

Can become a problem especially in teenage years – sharing of feelings is important. Parents can show frustration with some of the behaviours of the disabled child, and yet show that the child is still loved in spite of this.

Guilt:

Responsibility – feeling that something one said or did caused the child’s problem.

Survivor guilt:

Why not me?

Normal sibling conflict:

Unnecessarily sparing the child.

Isolation:

Within and without the family; some social opportunities are restricted or limited and some unfair responsibilities may fall on the other siblings.

Social relationships for siblings:

Parents are often concerned that the normal siblings will be stigmatised because of the child with the disability. Evidence shows that this is not a problem. In fact, some siblings use their disabled brother or sister as a measuring stick towards others. If you don’t accept him / her then you are not a friend of mine.

Improving sibling relationships:

Let children see that a certain behaviour can frustrate parents too, but they can love the child in spite of this.

MOST FAMILIES ARE VERY SUCCESSFUL IN COPING WITH A CHILD WITH A DISORDER, BUT THE HOW HAS NOT YET BEEN DEFINED.

Which issues will be important as we all get older:

Parents often assume communication as taken place, but if the children were too young at the time, they may not have properly understood. Hereditary factors will have to be clear, as in-laws and more children are planned.

Recommended reading: "A Difference in the Family" by Helen Featherston.

"A handicap inevitably changes the experience of each child in the family, but exceptional families offer normal children unusual opportunities as well as unusual problems." H. Featherston, 1980.

Please select a "Flame" link to read more...

Copyright 2001 Epilepsy Queensland Incorporated
Designed by NETworkers Pty Ltd - www.networkers.com.au